Who Won the Fight Between Katie Taylor and Amanda Serrano? Last night, July 11, 2025, Madison Square Garden was electric with anticipation as two of women’s boxing’s biggest stars, Katie Taylor and Amanda Serrano, faced off in their highly anticipated trilogy fight. This wasn’t just another boxing match—it was the culmination of one of the greatest rivalries in the sport’s history, headlining the first-ever all-women’s professional boxing card at the iconic venue. Fans from Ireland, Puerto Rico, and beyond packed the arena, and millions tuned in on Netflix to witness the clash for Taylor’s undisputed super lightweight titles. So, who won? Let’s break it down.
Table of Contents
The History of an Epic Rivalry
Katie Taylor and Amanda Serrano have been intertwined in boxing lore since their first meeting in April 2022. That fight, also at Madison Square Garden, was a landmark moment—the first women’s bout to headline the venue. Taylor, the Irish sensation and undisputed lightweight champion at the time, edged out Serrano, a seven-division world champion from Puerto Rico, by a razor-thin split decision. The fight was so thrilling it earned Sports Illustrated’s Fight of the Year and The Ring’s Event of the Year. Their rematch in November 2024, on the undercard of Jake Paul vs. Mike Tyson in Texas, was just as intense. Taylor won again, this time by unanimous decision, though controversy swirled due to a point deduction for headbutting and a gruesome cut above Serrano’s eye.
This third fight was billed as the tiebreaker, a chance to settle the score. Both fighters had something to prove: Taylor, at 39, wanted to cement her legacy as one of the greatest female boxers ever, while Serrano, 36, was hungry to flip the script and claim the undisputed super lightweight crown. The stakes couldn’t have been higher, and the atmosphere reflected it—Irish flags waved, Puerto Rican chants echoed, and the energy was palpable.
The Fight: A Tactical Chess Match
Unlike their first two slugfests, which saw a combined 871 punches landed, this trilogy bout was more measured, almost cautious at times. From the opening bell, both fighters seemed wary. Taylor, known for her crisp counterpunching, held the center of the ring, flicking jabs and looking to land clean shots. Serrano, typically a pressure fighter, opted for a more reserved approach, perhaps mindful of the headbutts that marred their second fight. The first round was so tentative some scored it 10-10, with neither landing anything significant.
As the rounds progressed, Taylor found her rhythm, using her footwork to keep Serrano at bay and landing sharper, more eye-catching punches. Serrano, despite her reputation as a harder puncher, struggled to close the distance effectively. She landed a notable left hook in the third round that caused a bruise under Taylor’s eye, but it wasn’t enough to shift momentum. By the seventh and ninth rounds, Taylor’s precision and ring generalship seemed to pull her ahead, though Serrano had moments, particularly in the sixth, where her flurries hinted at her trademark aggression.
The fight never reached the fever pitch of their earlier encounters. CompuBox stats showed only 140 punches landed combined, a stark contrast to the 541 in their 2024 rematch. Serrano later explained she chose to box at range to avoid Taylor’s clinches, but this played into Taylor’s hands, as the Irishwoman excels at picking opponents apart from the outside. The crowd, expecting another barnburner, was left wanting more action, but the tactical masterclass was undeniable.
The Verdict: Taylor Takes the Trilogy
After ten rounds, the judges’ scorecards were read: 95-95, 97-93, and 97-93, giving Katie Taylor the victory by majority decision. The announcement drew mixed reactions—cheers from the Irish contingent, boos from Serrano’s supporters. Taylor, now 25-1 with 6 KOs, retained her IBF, WBA, WBC, WBO, and Ring super lightweight titles, going 3-0 against Serrano (47-4-1, 31 KOs). Some, like ESPN’s Andreas Hale, felt the fight was close enough to be a draw, while others on X, like @the_red_bull1, argued Taylor’s cleaner shots and control in key rounds (7, 9, and 10) made her the clear winner.
Serrano, gracious in defeat, spoke of the honor of sharing the ring with Taylor. “We made history three times,” she said, acknowledging the groundbreaking nature of their trilogy. Taylor echoed the sentiment, thanking God, her team, and Serrano for their shared legacy. Both ruled out a fourth fight, with Serrano saying, “I’m kind of tired of Katie Taylor,” and Taylor focusing on her next challenges, possibly a rematch with Chantelle Cameron.
What’s Next for Women’s Boxing?
This fight wasn’t just about Taylor and Serrano—it was a celebration of women’s boxing. The all-female card, featuring five world title fights and a record 17 titles on the line, showcased the sport’s depth. Alycia Baumgardner defended her super featherweight titles, Ellie Scotney unified the super bantamweight division, and Shadasia Green’s split-decision win over Savannah Marshall set up a potential clash with Claressa Shields. The event, streamed globally on Netflix, proved women’s boxing is no longer a sideshow but a main attraction.
For Taylor, this win solidifies her as a legend. At 39, she’s still at the top, with a resume that includes Olympic gold, undisputed titles in two weight classes, and victories over one of the sport’s most formidable fighters. Serrano, despite the loss, remains a trailblazer, holding titles in seven weight classes and proving she can compete at the highest level across divisions. Their rivalry has elevated women’s boxing, drawing millions of viewers and shattering glass ceilings.
As the dust settles, the debate over the scorecards will linger, but the legacy of Taylor vs. Serrano is undeniable. They’ve made history three times, and their names will forever be linked in boxing lore. For now, Katie Taylor stands tall as the victor, but both warriors have won the respect of fans worldwide.
Sources: ESPN, Yahoo Sports, The Guardian, Netflix Tudum