Who Died When Trisha Paytas Had Elvis? Trisha Paytas, a polarizing YouTube star and podcaster, has been at the center of a bizarre internet conspiracy theory that links the births of her children to the deaths of prominent figures. When her second daughter, Elvis Paytas-Hacmon, was born on May 24, 2024, social media erupted with speculation about who might have passed away to fuel the ongoing “Trisha Paytas baby reincarnation theory.” Let’s dive into this wild internet phenomenon, exploring its origins, the events surrounding Elvis’s birth, and why it’s captured so much attention.
Table of Contents
The Origins of the Trisha Paytas Baby Reincarnation Theory
The conspiracy theory began in September 2022, when Trisha gave birth to her first daughter, Malibu Barbie Paytas-Hacmon, just six days after Queen Elizabeth II’s death on September 8, 2022. The timing sparked a viral joke on platforms like X, where users humorously suggested that Malibu was the queen’s reincarnation. Trisha initially leaned into the meme, noting on her podcast Just Trish that Malibu gave her “Queen Elizabeth vibes.” But the theory gained new life when Trisha announced her second pregnancy in November 2023, and it exploded again with Elvis’s birth. The internet loves a good coincidence, and Trisha’s pregnancies seem to provide plenty of fuel for speculation.
What Happened When Elvis Was Born?
Elvis Paytas-Hacmon arrived on May 24, 2024, and Trisha shared the joyful news on Instagram, posting adorable photos of her newborn in a pink polka-dot blanket. Unlike her first pregnancy, which coincided closely with Queen Elizabeth’s passing, no major public figure’s death was directly tied to Elvis’s birth date. However, the internet had already been buzzing with speculation months earlier, when King Charles III announced his cancer diagnosis in February 2024, while Trisha was pregnant. Memes flooded X, joking that her second child, named Elvis (a nod to “The King” Elvis Presley), might be Charles’s reincarnation if his health declined. Thankfully, King Charles was still alive as of Elvis’s birth, but the lack of a specific death didn’t stop the memes from rolling in.
The Pope Francis Connection
The theory took another twist when Pope Francis was falsely rumored to have died in April 2025, shortly before Elvis’s birth. Although the Pope was still alive at the time, social media users speculated that Trisha’s second child could be his reincarnation. Trisha addressed this on her Just Trish podcast, expressing frustration with the ongoing jokes. “I just don’t get it,” she said. “Is it just any influential person that dies gets to come reincarnated as my baby?” The Pope Francis rumor was debunked, but it highlighted how the internet latches onto any major figure’s death or illness to keep the conspiracy alive.
Why Does This Theory Persist?
The Trisha Paytas baby reincarnation theory thrives because of the internet’s love for absurdity and coincidence. Trisha’s larger-than-life persona, combined with her unique baby names like Malibu Barbie and Elvis, makes her an easy target for memes. The theory also taps into a cultural fascination with celebrity and mortality, blending humor with a touch of the supernatural. Social media platforms like X amplify these jokes, with posts like, “If I had a nickel for every time Trisha Paytas’ baby coincided with the downfall of the royal family, I’d have two nickels,” gaining thousands of likes. Trisha’s own reactions—sometimes leaning into the humor, other times asking people to “leave my babies alone”—only add to the buzz.
Trisha’s Response and the Bigger Picture
Trisha has had mixed feelings about the conspiracy. While she initially found the Queen Elizabeth jokes amusing, the constant speculation, especially around King Charles’s health, has made her uncomfortable. In a February 2024 TikTok, she said, “I get the meme of it all, but it terrifies me that people believe in it enough.” She’s emphasized that her children—Malibu, Elvis, and her third child, Aquaman, born in July 2025—are their own individuals, not reincarnations of anyone. The theory, while funny to some, underscores how quickly internet rumors can spiral, turning personal milestones into global conspiracies. As Trisha continues her journey as a mom, it’s clear the internet will keep watching, ready to link her next milestone to another wild theory.